2 Chicago Cubs weaknesses that have to be addressed in 2024
The 2023 Chicago Cubs had a number of weak links that are no longer with the team. Is that addition by subtraction enough?
The Chicago Cubs are running it back in 2024 with a very similar roster to the one they missed the playoffs with in 2023 which has led some to say that they’ve had one of the most disappointing offseasons in Major League Baseball.
It’s great to have Cody Bellinger back, and if that had happened earlier in the offseason there’s a chance that we could have avoided that not-so-superlative. However, even with him back the only way for this team to go from the outside of the playoff race to having a legitimate shot is to improve, and the Cubs may have targeted the right guys to do that.
According to Jay Jaffe at Fangraphs, the Cubs had the 24th adjusted WAR from catchers last season and the 25th adjusted WAR for first basemen, but those are the only two obvious areas where the 2023 Cubs were below league average.
Catcher
The Cubs will improve simply by subtraction without Tucker Barnhart acting as an anchor to this group. Last season he was worth -0.5 WAR in just 123 plate appearances by carrying a .202/.285/.257 slash line and collecting just four extra-base hits. To those that would point to his defense, he was worth -0.1 WAR according to Baseball Reference behind the dish as well, so that doesn’t hold water.
Beyond the loss of Barnhart the Cubs figure to give Miguel Amaya a much more even split with Yan Gomes than last season where Gomes played more than twice as many games (116) than Amaya (53). Last season was Amaya’s first in the majors after a series of unfortunate injury setbacks that held the former top prospect back and it’s reasonable to expect him to improve in 2024.
While Amaya’s second-half numbers last season were demonstrably worse across the board than his first-half numbers, there’s hope throughout the organization that he can be the guy he was in June that hit .294/.429/.529 while playing league-average defense. He’s still just 24 years old, so expecting a jump forward isn’t completely unreasonable.
First Base
Much like catcher, the Cubs carried three players last season that were absolutely abysmal in terms of WAR at first base. Matt Mervis (-0.4), Eric Hosmer (-0.5), and Trey Mancini (-1.4) combined for a legitimately mind-blowing -2.3 WAR at first base so simply not having them on the Major League roster should help.
Beyond that, the Cubs made a trade for Michael Busch. To be fair, he also had a -0.5 WAR with the Dodgers last season, but the Cubs believe in his bat. He’s been a top 100 prospect four years in a row according to Baseball America and in AAA last season he hit .323/.431/.618 with 27 homers. Yes, he’s a rookie. And yes, he had a rough cup of coffee at the end of last season. But keep in mind, we don’t need Anthony Rizzo or Derrek Lee at first base to be better than we were last season. We just need him to not be a net negative.
The final thing to keep in mind here is that Cody Bellinger is more than capable of playing first base as proven by the fact that he’s won a Gold Glove at the position. The Cubs have Pete Crow-Armstrong waiting in the wings to take over center field, so if Busch struggles there’s a greater-than-zero possibility that the Cubs have Bellinger play first and give another top prospect a shot while Busch figures it out.
Conclusion
The Cubs missed the playoffs by one game in 2023. Through subtraction of deadweight alone they’ll be adding 2.8 WAR to their team and there’s reason to believe in the direction that they’re moving with roster additions and players gaining experience. While this team didn’t make a ton of moves in the offseason, they may just be good enough to get to the playoffs this season and at that point anything is possible.