For the first time this season, the Chicago Cubs were swept in a three-game series. The Cubs fell to the San Francisco Giants 4-3 on Thursday, and it felt like a game where the Cubs couldn't catch a break. Making things even worse was that home plate umpire David Rackley had a bad day at the office.
Umpire David Rackley called the worst game of the day.
— Umpire Auditor (@UmpireAuditor) August 29, 2025
He missed 16 calls in the Giants Cubs game for a correct call rate of only 86.4%. pic.twitter.com/YBsUZv9pPI
We're not saying that Rackley being terrible at his job is the reason why the Cubs lost on Thursday, but it just speaks to the reason why the automatic ball-strike challenge needs to arrive in Major League Baseball next season. Of course, before then, when an umpire is bad at his job, Craig Counsell will make sure they are aware of that fact.
Craig Counsell has been ejected from today's Cubs-Giants game. pic.twitter.com/O5idI70NXT
— Marquee Sports Network (@WatchMarquee) August 28, 2025
Cubs loss to Giants stings more after umpire's bad calls come to light
Counsell is never going to have a reaction that rivals Willson Contreras, but when the Cubs' offense is struggling to score runs as it is, his frustrations likely boiled over with Rackley's poor performance.
The good news is that arguing over strike calls could come to an end as soon as next season. After testing the ABS challenge system in spring training this season, there will be an effort to bring it to the regular season. If implemented, it would dramatically change instances like what occurred with Counsell and the Cubs on Thursday. If a player doesn't agree with the call, they can tap their helmet to indicate a challenge, and the system will remove the drama from the situation.
Of course, complaining about the accuracy of a home plate umpire speaks to how far off track the Cubs' season has become. Sure, the Cubs remain on a path to reach the playoffs, but their offense has lacked the firepower they had at the start of the season. If Kyle Tucker, Pete Crow-Armstrong, and Seiya Suzuki were swinging the bat like they were during the early months of the season, chances are the home plate umpire's awful day wouldn't have even been noticed on Thursday.
