Skip to main content

Cubs should remember Edward Cabrera lesson before pursuing MacKenzie Gore trade

Chicago hasn't shown it can make the most of project pitchers, regardless of potential.
ByJake Misener
Richard Rodriguez/GettyImages

I don't know about you, but I haven't forgotten talking myself into Edward Cabrera's tremendous upside last winter after the Chicago Cubs sent top-100 prospect Owen Caissie to the Miami Marlins in exchange for the right-hander.

Fast-forward 10 months and, well, we all know how that story played out. Instead of taking his game to new heights, Cabrera backslid - dramatically - struggling to a 5.96 ERA and hitting the injured list for multiple ailments throughout the year. One bad season doesn't write the full story of his Cubs tenure, but it was certainly a tough first impression.

His regression only exacerbates a major Cubs' problem this winter: a lack of starting pitching. I wish it was just about a lack of front-of-the-rotation pitching, but it runs much deeper than that. Cabrera was supposed to be ready to step up and lead this rotation heading into 2027, but he's probably the biggest question mark among the returning starters.

If Dustin May's free-agent deal with the Chicago White Sox is any indication, the Cubs could once again be forced to pivot to the trade market this winter. Enter the latest rumors swirling around Texas Rangers' lefty MacKenzie Gore, who has one year of team control remaining and is drawing widespread interest ahead of the anticipated lockout next month.

According to The Athletic (subscription required), the Rangers are fielding interest in Gore, a former first-round pick who has always looked enticing given his stuff and upside, but is yet to put it all together over the course of an entire season. Last year in Texas, he led the league with 34 starts, working to a 4.58 ERA (3.87 FIP) across 173 innings of work.

He's been a workhorse, which is something that would surely be of interest to a Cubs team that had just one pitcher eclipse 140 innings last year (Shota Imanaga). The fact that he sits in the mid-90s with his fastball and has struck out a quarter of the batters he's faced in his career doesn't hurt, either.

2 reasons a MacKenzie Gore trade is a huge gamble for the Cubs

OK, so he's got some velo and can miss bats. Why shouldn't Jed Hoyer get aggressive here? Well, for two reasons. First, Gore is a free agent after the 2027 season. We have no idea how many games will be played next year as the owners and MLBPA prepare for a contentious labor battle. That makes two teams agreeing on a value in such a deal incredibly complicated.

Second, well, I don't exactly have a lot of faith in the Cubs' ability to unlock that 'next level' for a pitcher like Gore, who's always been intriguing, but is yet to translate that upside it to consistent results. The Cabrera trade, at least in the short-term, looks like a total disaster. Doubling down on that approach with a Gore trade and having that be the 'big' move in the rotation? You're just asking for trouble.

Add us as a preferred source on Google