Skip to main content

Cubs lose Dustin May sweepstakes to White Sox in a eye-opening crosstown overpay

Is the market about to pick up?
ByJordan Campbell
World Series: Milwaukee Brewers v Tampa Bay Rays - Game Four
World Series: Milwaukee Brewers v Tampa Bay Rays - Game Four | Carmen Mandato/GettyImages

The Chicago Cubs were among the teams believed to be interested in free-agent starting pitcher Dustin May, but it is the Chicago White Sox who will walk away from the offseason with the former Milwaukee Brewers starter. The White Sox signed May to a three-year contract worth $50 million, representing the first move of consequence for starting pitchers on the free-agent market.

Starting pitching is the priority for the Cubs this offseason, and there's an expectation that the team will add three established pitchers ot their rotation. While May was once a promising prospect with the Los Angeles Dodgers, and he had some early success, his recent years have proven him to be more of a project instead of an established option for a starting rotation.

Look no further than this past trade deadline. The Brewers acquired May from the St. Louis Cardinals with the hope that he could bolster the team's rotation down the stretch. Instead, May posted a 5.65 ERA in 10 starts with the Brewers. During Milwaukee's World Series, he wasn't exactly factored into the Brewers' rotation plans, but he did make two postseason starts.

Cubs avoid a massive overpay as White Sox jump free-agent market with Dustin May overpay

Similar to the Cubs, the White Sox entered the offseason with a need for pitching. Though, unlike their crosstown rival, the South Siders weren't constructing their rotation from scratch. Perhaps that is why they felt comfortable giving May $50 million over the next three years.

For the Cubs, that type of deal would have been a reach. The Cubs signing May wouldn't have been viewed as the team finding their no-doubt addition to the rotation. In a scenario where the Cubs added May and two other pitchers, he likely would have been viewed as the biggest project of the group.

Along those lines, the Cubs deciding not to match the White Sox's contract for May, assuming they were afforded the chance, does suggest that team isn't desperate for pitching to the extent that they will force themselves into bad contract, May, in his current form, would arrive with more questions than answers, and the Cubs weren't going to be the team to jump his market.

Now that a starting pitcher is off the board, though, this could be the trigger for more activity in the days ahead. There's no time for the Cubs to waste, considering their starting rotation currently looks like a blank canvas.

Add us as a preferred source on Google