As we wait for the Chicago Cubs to really start adding to their roster ahead of the lockout in December, there's another low-risk flier that may have already caught Jed Hoyer's attention.
While the Cubs have yet to make a move of consequence this offseason, Hoyer has found reclamation projects. The Cubs have claimed veterans Eric Orze and Chayce McDermott off waivers, and signed former Pittsburgh Pirates reliever Justin Lawrence to a minor-league deal. There likely will be more deals of this variety, and one that could be slightly more expensive is making an upside play on former New York Mets starting pitcher Frankie Montas.
Montas missed all of the 2026 season while recovering from Tommy John surgery, but recently threw a bullpen session in front of a handful of teams. Considering the need the Cubs have for pitching, it would be fair to suggest the North Siders were in attendance.
Despite flashing some potential in his early years with the Athletics, Montas never quite put it together for a full season. He was a deadline addition for the New York Yankees in 2022, but posted an ERA of 6.35 across his first eight starts in New York. His 2023 was wiped away due to injury, and when he returned in 2024, it was clear that he's become much more of a project instead of someone with established expectations.
We last saw Montas in 2025 with the Mets, before the Tommy Surgery, and he posted a 6.28 ERA in just under 39 innings pitched.
Cubs shouldn't dismiss a Frankie Montas bargain (but there's a catch)
As for the bullpen, reports were that his fastball was in line with his career average, 95 MPH, and topped out at 98 MPH. Montas' mechanics were also encouraging. While conventional wisdom would point to Montas being a minor-league signing, the evaluators in attendance during his bullpen session suggested that he could get a big-league deal. Even so, considering the injury history and what he looked like when he was last healthy, it's hard to imagine the deal would be all that expensive.
Under the right circumstance, it could be a worthwhile signing for the Cubs. Especially when you consider that when Montas was right, his ground-ball rate was hovering around 45%.
To be clear, though, the Cubs can't view Montas as someone who should be handed a spot in the rotation. It's even possible that the best way to use him may be through the bullpen. That's the condition for the Cubs. This can't be sold as a move to help the starting rotation immediately in 2027. If it does, great. But, realistically, Montas would be best-served as a low-risk project for the coaching staff, assuming there are larger additions made this offseason.
