While the goal for the Chicago Cubs is to add at least one starting pitcher to their rotation before the lockout on December 1, Jed Hoyer is also going to do what he does best and search for diamonds in the rough. The latest, in which, comes in the form of signing former Pittsburgh Pirates relief pitcher Justin Lawrence to a minor-league deal.
This is the typical upside play that Hoyer looks for in November, though, considering the time crunch specific to this offseason, he's probably not going to be given the benefit of the doubt.
After posting a 0.51 ERA with the Pirates across 17 appearances in 2025, there was hope in Pittsburgh that Lawrence could have a larger role in the bullpen this season. Instead, he posted a 5.32 ERA in his first 23 appearances. He then had a pair of stops with the Minnesota Twins and Washington Nationals, and had similar results.
Cubs' latest bullpen project arrives in the form of former Pirates pitcher Justin Lawrence
Lawrence's profile fits the one the Cubs typically seek when taking these low-risk fliers during the offseason. Lawrence has a side-arm delivery that helps his sweeper generate whiffs, and a sinker that sits in the mid-90s. With regard to his sweeper, it carried a whiff rate over 45% last season.
For the Cubs, the value in pitchers with a heavy sinker is that it should lead to an increased ability to keep the ball on the ground. It was only seven appearances with the Nationals at the end of the season, but Lawrence's ground-ball rate was over 55%. Entering the offseason, the expectation was that the Cubs would seek pitchers capable of keeping the ball on the ground, or able to miss bats frequently.
Lawrence has the ability to do both, but the primary reason why he's struggled over the course of his career is due to his command. Lawrence's career walk-rate is nearly 13%. If he's going to have any future in the Cubs' bullpen, that number will need to come down.
It's an uninspiring move, considering all that has to be done by the Cubs this offseason, but these simply are the moves that Hoyer and Co. are never going to turn away from them. Finding these under-the-radar arms is how the Cubs prefer to find secure bullpen depth, and it's worth noting that Aaron Civale, Trent Thornton, and Colin Rea were among the free agents the Cubs had this winter. One way or another, they need to replenish the well of bullpen arms available at this disposal.
