Skip to main content

Cubs made the easy Jaxon Wiggins decision but larger question remains

Keep pitching when you got it.
ByJordan Campbell
2026 MiLB Field of Dreams: St. Paul Saints v Iowa Cubs
2026 MiLB Field of Dreams: St. Paul Saints v Iowa Cubs | Daniel Shirey/GettyImages

Protecting each pitching prospect from a potential Rule 5 draft this offseason, the Chicago Cubs selected Jaxon Wiggins and Brody McCullough to their 40-man roster on Tuesday. In an offseason where pitching is the focus for Jed Hoyer and Co., Wiggins being added to the 40-man roster was a foregone conclusion, and suddenly, it looks like McCullough could be an option for the 2027 pitching staff.

McCullough was drafted by the Cubs in 2022, and after missing all of the 2025 season with injury, he returned near the end of the 2026 season. In nine appearances with Double-A Knoxville, McCullough posted an ERA of 2.98 while striking out over 26% of the hitters he faced.

26 years old, assuming health, it would seem there's a viable chance of McCullough making his way to Wrigley Field by the end of the 2027 season.

Cubs add Jaxon Wiggins to 40-man roster, his role moving forward remains unclear

When a lack of pitching prospects defined the Cubs' farm system, Jaxon Wiggins was the exception. Over the years, Wiggins was largely viewed as the best pitching prospect the Cubs had, and in 2025, he was pretty close to untouchable status in terms of prospects Hoyer was willing to part with in a trade.

Since then, the shine on Wiggins' prospect has worn off. He's struggled to stay on the field, and when he has pitched, there's been issues with his command. Across 18 appearances with the Iowa Cubs in 2026, Wiggins posted an ERA of 7.83 while walking over 19% of the hitters he faced.

Towards the end of the 2026 season, the Cubs did move Wiggins to the bullpen, and he did see better results. He posted a 3.97 ERA across 11 relief appearances, but the context is that nine of his 11 outings were scoreless. Still, one of the primary reasons why he didn't called to the Cubs to close out the season, he was walking over 16% of the hitters he faced.

First and foremost, before Wiggins has any role with the Cubs, he will need to figure out his command issues. When he's right, he still had the stuff to miss bats, but his walk-rate was at the level that it would be a liability for a big-league pitching staff. With that in mind, it would seem that Wiggins' future with the Cubs will likely be as a reliever, and not the top-of-the-rotation starter the Cubs once expected him to be.

Add us as a preferred source on Google