Chicago Cubs Rumors: Jacob deGrom would drastically alter this club

3 of 4

Adding Jacob deGrom could take the Chicago Cubs from a favorite in the National League to a legitimate threat to win a second World Series in three years.

With the All-Star Game taking place Tuesday night in Washington, D.C., much will undoubtedly be made of the American League-National League rivalry. More importantly, though, how the best clubs in each league (like the Chicago Cubs) stack up against one another.

And, as happy as I am with how the Cubs finished the first half, the American League, at least right now, looks like the drastically stronger of the two. The Houston Astros and Boston Red Sox look like they’re destined to match up come October. Meanwhile, Chicago leads a weaker National League.

When you look specifically at a team like Houston, their rotation looms large. We’re talking about facing some combination of Justin Verlander, Gerrit Cole, Dallas Kuechel, Lance McCullers Jr. and Charlie Morton. Whoever didn’t make the rotation in a postseason series would loom large in the pen.

What could the Cubs do to even the field a bit? Trade for a likely Cy Young finalist in the New York Mets’ Jacob deGrom. Such an acquisition surely won’t be easy. Nor will it come cheap. But with the right-hander in-tow, the Cubs match up on paper against any team in the American League.

(Photo by Patrick McDermott/Getty Images) /

Chicago Cubs: Examining what he brings to the table

deGrom, a two-time All-Star, has set the bar for National League starters in 2018. He leads the league in ERA+ (228), FIP (2.32) and earned run average (1.68) in 123 1/3 innings of work for a lowly Mets club.

The big right-hander has long been heralded as one of the most promising arms in baseball. But, as we know, Mets hurlers also come with a warning label given their seemingly endless merry-go-round on the disabled list. But, for the most part, deGrom has been consistent.

From 2014 to 2017, he’s averaged 170 innings per season with a 2.98 ERA, 3.07 FIP and 4.15 strikeout-to-walk ratio. This season, he may very well eclipse 200 frames of work for the first time in his career.

And as far as his stuff goes? He’s downright filthy. With New York needing a rebuild, no one will fetch more to jump start such a project than their ace. But, when you look at the Cubs, how you shuffle the pitching staff is more than a little hairy.

Chicago Cubs: Once Darvish returns, Cubs have questions to answer

Right now, the Cubs have the following starting five: Jon Lester, Kyle Hendricks, Jose Quintana, Tyler Chatwood and Mike Montgomery. The ace? Lester. Hendricks and Quintana are yet to pitch up to expectations, while Chatwood increasingly looks like the reincarnation of Edwin Jackson.

More from Cubbies Crib

The biggest question mark, though, is the team’s offseason prize, Yu Darvish. He hasn’t pitched in two months and nobody really seems to know what the issue is in his $126 million right arm. For all we know, he’ll be back a couple weeks after the All-Star Break. Or, he won’t throw another pitch this season.

Let’s play hypotheticals

So, for argument’s sake, let’s say the Cubs pulled off a deGrom trade in the next two weeks. Then, in a month, Darvish returns from the disabled list. At least at face value, I’d assume Chatwood and Montgomery head to the bullpen. But, then, you have to consider the financial implications.

The club inked Chatwood to a three-year, $39 million deal this offseason. That’s a lot of money to shell out to a fifth starter – let a lone a long man in the pen. Montgomery would be easier to solve. The Cubs may opt to stick with six starters – or shift him back to the pen, where he’s spent most of his time in Chicago.

All told, it’s a big question mark. No one knows how this would play out. For all we know, Theo Epstein and Jed Hoyer may line up a subsequent deal to make something with deGrom work. But they’d risk weakening the team’s pitching depth in doing so – and, in doing nothing, they have a logjam in the starting rotation.

Chicago Cubs: Adding deGrom would impact team’s depth

The days where the Cubs could trade a heralded prospect yet to see the light of a Major League ballpark are gone. At least for the time being. Eloy Jimenez? Gone. Dylan Cease? A teammate of Jimenez on the South Side. Gleyber Torres? An All-Star for the New York Yankees.

To pull off such a deal, the Cubs are going to lose major big league chips. We’re talking Albert Almora, Addison Russell, Ian Happ, Kyle Schwarber-type guys. Throwing David Bote or Victor Caratini at a team in this instance won’t do much at all.

Can you stomach losing a handful of guys off the roster? And, while adding a top-tier arm certainly improves the starting rotation, what would it do to the positional depth the Cubs have become known for in recent years?

Next: Are Cubs looking to buy low on O's Britton?

At that point, the Cubs’ brass makes the call: what’s more valued for a team with World Series aspirations? Do you hope the rotation carries the load deep into October and go with Tommy La Stella, David Bote and Victor Caratini picking up regular at-bats as your depth guys?

Or do you put your faith where you have in the last three years – a young core that’s currently unrivaled in the league? At some point, the rotation has to improve and, when they do, the Cubs may not have as big a need as some suggest.

Home / Chicago Cubs Rumors