Chicago Cubs: Stop making Kyle Hendricks the next Maddux

Just because he’s an average height white guy who throws in the mid-80s and plays for the Cubs doesn’t mean Kyle Hendricks is the second coming of Greg Maddux.

On Kyle Hendricks’ Baseball Reference page, you won’t see Greg Maddux’s name in his most similar players.  And you won’t see Hendricks on Maddux’s page either.

Greg Maddux is astronomically better than Hendricks.  That doesn’t mean that Hendricks isn’t a good pitcher, he’s one of the best in the NL.

I’m sick of this narrative that’s being forced on Kyle Hendricks which is almost impossible to live up to.

The stat difference between the two shows who is the superior pitcher.

It’s easier for us to judge who Greg Maddux was since he is retired, but we still don’t know who Kyle Hendricks is or what he will become.

The sample size of Hendricks is still pretty small since he only has four seasons under his belt.  Similar to a lot of 2017 Cubs, he is having a down year from last year.

That could be because he played an extra month of baseball, which shouldn’t be taken for granted.  Or it could also be because he has battled some injuries, again which might have been caused by fatigue.

This year “The Professor” has a 3.22 ERA, a 4.13 FIP, and a WHIP of 1.181.  That isn’t the front of the rotation stuff we saw last year.

Could he be regressing to the mean or is this just a down year?  Nobody knows, but we have to be willing to consider 2015 might have been his max potential.

There’s also a question of dominance.  Maddux was dominant.  Hendricks hasn’t ever been dominant.

He’s not the kind of guy that can go out there and pitch a two-hit complete game on any given night.  Maddux also threw a lot more innings than Hendricks.

Last year, Hendricks threw 190 innings, his career high.  Maddux pitched 268 innings in 1992!  That just goes to show the difference in the eras as well.

There’s a reason why Greg Maddux is in the Hall of Fame.

By the way, Maddux should’ve gone in as a Brave.  Look at the numbers and tell me that man isn’t a Brave!

Anyway, Kyle Hendricks may be in Cooperstown one day; he may not.  Does that mean he isn’t a great pitcher?  Of course not.

I just don’t want to keep being fed this false narrative that Hendricks is the next Maddux It simply isn’t true, for now. It’s a great divide between the two, although Hendricks does have the opportunity to close it–at least a little bit.

Next: Nicasio makes sense for the Cubs

It’s possible that in 10 years, we’ll look back at this and say, “Wow, he really did turn into the next Maddux.” That’s the fun of baseball. You never know what’s going to happen.