Miles Mastrobuoni's roster move should signal end of dreadful Cubs' roster strategy

20 years from now, Chicago Cubs fans will be convening in the lobby of the hotel that is hosting the Cubs Convention, enjoying a nightcap while going through rounds of trivia. There will be an obscure question like who was the Cubs' Opening Day right fielder in 2023, and while Seiya Suzuki will be one of the first names that come to mind, that answer would be wrong. Miles Mastrobuoni was the Opening Day right fielder for the Cubs in 2023 due to Suzuki dealing with an oblique strain and it was a moment that began the polarizing fanfare for Mastrobuoni.

Prior to the 2023 season, the Cubs acquired Mastrobuoni from the Tampa Bay Rays for a player to be named later.

On the surface, there was plenty to like about the Cubs' addition of Mastrobuoni. Mastrobuoni was a utility infielder with a hit profile that suggested he could be a valuable piece off the bench. Part of the reason why Mastrobuoni drew the ire of Cubs' fans at the start of his time with the team is for reasons beyond his control.

Former Cubs' manager David Ross fell in love with Mastrobuoni and despite infrequent offensive success, the minor-league journeyman continued to find his way into the starting lineup.

A season later, Mastrobuoni may have played his final game in a Cubs uniform. Prior to their loss to the Philadelphia Phillies on Wednesday, the Cubs optioned Mastrobuoni to the Arizona Complex League in favor of one of their top prospects, Kevin Alcántara.

Miles Mastrobuoni's time with the Cubs may be nearing an end.

Ironically, it was a Suzuki injury that led to the move on Wednesday.

But, with the move, the Cubs should end the dreadful roster strategy they have with their bench. The Cubs' front office, as well as Ross and Craig Counsell, value versatility over production. This season alone, Mastrobuoni had a 36 wRC+ but managed to still stack together 106 plate appearances.

What the Cubs need to learn is that just because a player can play multiple positions doesn't mean they have value to being on a Major League team's bench. As the Cubs are constructing their 2025 roster, there shouldn't be this preference for players like Mastrobuoni. Especially when the Cubs have prospects such as James Triantos, who could serve in that role with a higher offensive profile.