Chicago Cubs Rumors: Top three remaining catchers on the board
Unfortunately, the Chicago Cubs are still docked after missing out on Christian Vazquez and Sean Murphy while other teams are already heading for open waters. They must abandon their previous philosophies of two-way compatibility and acquire whoever they can to point the ship in the right direction. They missed several key free agents they were connected to. Kodai Senga and Chris Bassitt have signed, essentially taking care of that upper-middle tier group of starters. Christian Vazquez signed, and the Braves traded for Sean Murphy. In one day, the top two catching targets are off the board for the Cubs.
Do the walls feel like they're starting to close in on a competitive 2023 season? Yes. And the reality is they are beginning to. Unless Jed Hoyer swiftly pivots now and secures a couple of top available bats, the optimism will undoubtedly continue to shrink. You have the right to be pessimistic at this point. If you're anything like I am and still digging (deeper and deeper) for the optimistic approach, then let's continue to look at the top three remaining catchers on the board. There are still guys that are solid enough to bring something to the table for the Cubs next year.
Top 3 remaining targets - 3. Omar Narvaez
In 2022, Omar Narvaez was limited to just 84 games due to a couple of 10-day IL stints and mostly platooning against RHPs. He had a down year at the plate, slashing just .206/.292/.305. Previously, Narvaez has had success with the bat, averaging a .276/.361/.412 from 2016-2019 and then a line of .266/.342/.402 in 2021. More often than not, he's been just fine behind the plate from a batting average and getting on-base perspective.
Defensively, it's not the prettiest. Narvaez ranks 21st among active catchers with a 21.61% caught-stealing percentage. For the Cubs to get value out of him, his bat must come alive in the lineup. Out of the three available on this list, he's probably my 3rd option. I do like what he can do offensively, but the lack of defense aligns differently with Jed Hoyer's need for a two-way catcher that brings offense and defense to the team. At this point, though, they'll need to secure anybody they can. The options are slimming quickly.
Top 3 remaining targets - 2. Mike Zunino
Target number 2 that the Cubs can go after is Mike Zunino. Inserting him into your hypothetical lineup at least gives you a sense of optimism, as he's eclipsed the 20-homer plateau four times in his career. Most recently, Zunino launched 33 baseballs into orbit in 2021. Fast forwarding to this year, Zunino only appeared in 36 contests due to left shoulder inflammation, clearly hindering his slash line of .148/.195/.304. Though he's never been one to hit for a high average anyway, the pop in his bat should be sought after this winter.
Defensively, like Narvaez before him, his caught-stealing percentage isn't the greatest, sitting at just north of 28%. He does call a good game. However, the Rays have always had fantastic pitching, which goes hand-in-hand with the man behind the plate. His 28% caught-stealing is only 1% behind Willson Contreras. He possesses a slightly higher ISO lifetime (.210 vs. .207) than Contreras. Zunino is an acceptable replacement at the very worst and is currently on top of the board regarding those remaining in the catching department.
Editor's Note: On Tuesday morning, Mike Zunino agreed to terms with the Cleveland Guardians.
Top 3 remaining targets - 1. Gary Sanchez
Gary Sanchez is still a viable catcher who appeared in 91 games behind the plate in 2022. Among those games, he recorded 618 putouts and just four errors, giving him a respectable .994 fielding percentage. On top of that, he always hits for power. He possesses a career of .242 ISO. Though he hit just 16 HRs this year, he has topped 30 twice and driven in up to 90 RBIs during his time with the Yankees. Not a hit-for-average type of guy, Sanchez's career slash line sits at .225/.311/.467.
He is in the same realm of caught-stealing percentage with 28.66%, currently directly behind Willson Contreras among all active leaders in the MLB by less than a fraction of a percent. A bit strangely, Sanchez has always been a reverse splits guy that hits righties better than he hits southpaws with slashes of .208/.315/.459 and .231/.310/.470, respectively. Therefore, it makes sense to platoon Sanchez vs. righties and Gomes against lefties a little bit here. After missing on the two bigger fish, this is the tier of catchers the Cubs will have to settle for. Though they could do far worst, they need not waste time and at least get one of these guys. Options are quickly dwindling.