3 prospects the Cubs should not trade, and 2 they should
The Chicago Cubs farm system is considered to be top ten in the league right now with several top 100 prospects sprinkled around their minor league affiliates. Not all of them will turn into big league stars or even be on the Cubs in the future. With a wealth of position players already at the big league level, some of the outfield prospects will undoubtedly be moved to acquire big league talent. Here are three prospects the Cubs should hold on to, and two they should trade.
Keep: RHP Ben Brown
Ben Brown has emerged as quite the prize from the 2022 trade deadline. The Cubs sent their closer David Robertson over to the Phillies in exchange for Brown last August, and the 6'6 right-hander recently earned a promotion to the Iowa Cubs. Although the adjustment to the Triple-A level was slow, Brown is beginning to settle in with a 2.25 ERA on the season.
As the Cubs' number 6 prospect, Brown is knocking on the major league door and could get the call as soon as this season. With high velocity and an impressive curveball, Brown could end up being a big league starter or transition into a high-leverage bullpen guy. Either way, Brown is too valuable to trade.
Trade: OF Pete Crow-Armstrong
That's right, I am on the trade Pete Crow-Armstrong train. I know that is not a popular opinion to have, but I think his trade value is through the roof right now and the Cubs should cash in no matter what their record looks like at the trade deadline. Crow-Armstrong is coming off a gold glove-winning season as a center fielder where he skyrocketed himself all the way to the top of the Cubs farm system.
He can run, field, and hit for contact. But here's the thing, the Cubs already have a guy on the team who can do all of those things and more. That guy's name is Cody Bellinger. The only difference is that Cody Bellinger is a proven big league player who has won Rookie of the Year, an MVP, a gold glove, and a World Series. I am more willing to gamble on Bellinger than I am with Crow-Armstrong so I say extend the former and trade the latter.
Keep: LHP Jordan Wicks
Jordan Wicks is arguably the best chance the Cubs have at developing their next big league starter. What sets him apart from Brown, Hayden Wesneski and Caleb Kilian is the fact that the Cubs drafted Wicks and have brought him all the way through their system to the point where he is about to get promoted to the Iowa Cubs. The soft-throwing lefty is dealing this year with a 2.40 ERA in 9 starts this year. Even though he doesn't overpower hitters, Wicks still strikes out a lot of hitters with 174 Ks in 143 minor league innings pitched. I'd expect to see Wicks at Wrigley Field by the end of 2023 whether it be in a starting or bullpen role.
Trade: RHP Cade Horton
2022 first-round pick Cade Horton has gained national attention without even completing a full professional season yet. After skipping over rookie ball and beginning the season with Myrtle Beach, Horton has already made his way to South Bend where he has yet to find his footing. Despite recent struggles, MLB has Horton listed as the 65th-best prospect in all of baseball. I say trade him.
Unlike Wicks and Brown, Horton is still years away from getting to the big league level despite his stock being so high. Since he came out of nowhere during the draft season and has a very small track record of success, the Cubs should see what they can get for their No. 2 prospect since the positional need at starting pitcher is low.
Keep: C Miguel Amaya
Catcher Miguel Amaya is arguably the most untradable prospect in the entire system. He is the catcher of the future for this team and he seems to impress every pitching staff he works with, including the major league squad earlier this year. His pitch calling and framing are elite, he has a good throwing arm and now his bat is finally emerging with a .969 OPS in the minors this year. It's only a matter of time before Amaya is called back up and they frankly could use him with Tucker Barnhart not serving as the greatest backup to Yan Gomes. The Cubs would be fools to trade Amaya.