3 Cubs players fighting for their futures heading into the 2024 season

Time's running out for these three players to prove they have a long-term role to play.

/ Allan Henry-USA TODAY Sports
3 of 3
Next

Two years ago, the state of the Chicago Cubs farm system left plenty to be desired, leading to the fanbase betting heavily on the top-ranked prospects and the haul that came over in the trade deadline deals that ended the Cubs tenure of Javier Baez, Anthony Rizzo, Kris Bryant and others.

Since that time, though, several of those new faces from two years ago have blossomed - and a combination of savvy trade deadline moves and strong draft positions have helped Jed Hoyer rebuild the team's minor league depth far more quickly than initially expected.

With the improved depth at pretty much every level of the organizational depth chart, though, the pressure is on several players to prove they have something to offer long-term. Let's look at 3 to see where they stand heading into 2024.

Caleb Kilian continues to show flashes, but still lacks consistency

After tossing two scoreless innings on Tuesday night, right-hander Caleb Kilian exited with Cubs trainers. The update wasn't great on Wednesday, with Craig Counsell calling the injury 'concerning' but one hopes it doesn't derail his entire campaign because Kilian is a guy who definitely has a lot riding on the 2024 season.

Part of the Kris Bryant trade back in 2021 along with Alexander Canario, Kilian ranked as the Cubs' #4-ranked prospect in 2022, before falling back to #23 last year and missing out on the top 30 altogether in this week's update from MLB Pipeline. No one is questioning his stuff, but the results just haven't followed.

Last season, he worked to a 4.56 ERA in 120 1/3 innings at Triple-A Iowa with a severely diminished strikeout rate. The handful of appearances at the big league level didn't go well either, so it's all eyes on the former top prospect in 2024 as he looks to get things back on track.


Chicago has built a contender and you can boost your bankroll ahead of the season with an instant bonus at BetMGM. You'll instantly win $150 in bonus bets if you sign up, deposit $10 or more and then bet $5 or more on ANY wager. Sign up with BetMGM with this Cubbies Crib link today!

It feels like the clock is ticking on Matt Mervis' time in a Cubs uniform

For all the hoopla that surrounded Matt Mervis' breakout 2022 season in the minors, there's little reason to believe the Cubs see him as a long-term solution at first base. This offseason, not only did they bring back Cody Bellinger, who will split time between center field and first, but they loaded up on depth at the latter position, trading for Michael Busch and bringing in no-risk flyers like Dominic Smith and Garrett Cooper, as well.

Busch will get plenty of runway early in the year to secure the job and with multiple bench options in the mix, there's just no clear path for Mervis to return to Wrigley anytime soon. Pair that with the fact the Cubs are even starting to get rising prospect Owen Caissie some reps at first and things quickly go from bad to worse for the former Duke standout.

Mervis' struggles in limited big-league action last year(.167/.242/.289 in 99 plate appearances) did him no favors and, as more time goes on, it feels more and more like his next big chance could come somewhere other than Chicago.

Injuries have derailed Brennen Davis' once-promising trajectory

Another guy who really couldn't handle another injury finds himself on this list while, unfortunately, working his way back from concussion protocol in Brennen Davis. The former top prospect has battled numerous injuries in recent years and, like Kilian, has fallen completely off MLB Pipeline's Cubs top 30 list.

During that same time, the Cubs' outfield prospect depth has significantly improved. Three of the team's top six prospects are outfielders (Pete Crow-Armstrong (1), Owen Caissie (3) and Kevin Alcantara (6).

Hopefully, there are no lingering effects from Davis' hit by pitch that put him into concussion protocol because perhaps no prospect in the entire organization needs a rebound season in quite the same way as he does. If he can't stay on the field and produce in 2024, it seems safe to say the Cubs will move forward without him factoring much into their long-term outlook.

feed

Next