Pete Crow-Armstrong's Silver Slugger nomination comes with one important question for 2027

FanSided has revealed the finalists for the Louisville Silver Sluggers, and it should come as no surprise that Chicago Cubs' center fielder Pete Crow-Armstrong is among them. He's joined by former teammate, Seiya Suzuki, along with Corbin Carroll, Jackson Chourio, Fernando Tatis Jr., Jordan Walker, and James Wood. Crow-Armstrong is the presumptive National League MVP, so it feels like a lock that he will be among the winners when they are announced.

No matter how you look at it, Crow-Armstrong's 2026 season was excellent. He slashed .280/.372/.570 with 45 home runs, and a wRC+ of 157. The Cubs signed Crow-Armstrong to a pre-arbitration extension at the start of the season, inking him to six-year deal worth $115 million. It was a gamble on Crow-Armstrong's ceiling, believing that he would be capable of becoming a superstar. Little did the Cubs know it would happen this soon.

What stands out the most from Crow-Armstrong's 2026 season was his plate discipline. He drew 83 walks last year. For reference, in 2025, Crow-Armstrong only walked 29 times. It led to 7% increase in his walk rate, and that is truly what made him a force at the top of the Cubs' starting lineup.

Pete Crow-Armstrong has another Silver Slugger nomination, but it comes with a question for 2027?

Along with the praise and recognition for the season that was for Crow-Armstrong, there's a question hiding in plain sight. Can Crow-Armstrong replicate the success he had?

The case can be made that the Cubs are gambling on the belief that he can. It doesn't seem that the Cubs will enter a bidding war for Suzuki this offseason, and chances are also likely that Ian Happ is elsewhere. Suzuki's loss will certainly have a greater impact than Happ, but collectively, losing both veteran outfielders would be a step back for the offense.

With Jed Hoyer having already ruled out the idea of their being a big-ticket addition to the offense this season, it would seem that he's betting on 2026 version of Crow-Armstrong being here to stay.

Overall, it's reasonable to say that a large part of what made Crow-Armstrong work this season can be done again in 2027. That said, right now, it feels likely that it won't be at the level that Crow-Armstrong has another 40-40 season with a 10.6 fWAR. Regression feels inevitable, and that is something the Cubs may want to account for this offseason.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Follow