One Cubs reality makes ESPN's Seiya Suzuki trade deadline suggestion fall apart

There's been no escaping Seiya Suzuki trade rumors for the Chicago Cubs. They've been around since the Cubs traded for Kyle Tucker ahead of the 2025 season, and with the 2026 MLB trade deadline less than a month away, Suzuki continues to be the subject of trade speculation.

ESPN's Jeff Passan and Kiley McDaniel updated their power ranking of trade candidates earlier this week, and while the Cubs were linked to just about every starting pitcher mentioned, Suzuki was listed at No. 14.

The ESPN insiders place a 15% chance on Suzuki being moved, but their rationale for the Cubs making the move, doesn't quite make sense.

"Considering the paucity of impact outfielders available, Chicago could try to take advantage of the market and lean into its depth with Michael Conforto and Kevin Alcantara."

Generally, there's not a ton of established position players available ahead of the deadline. There's a handful of controllable bats who could be traded, but for now, most of those conversations feel like a thought exercise instead of actual speculation. Suzuki falls under that category as well, with the only exception being that he's a rental.

The biggest reason the Cubs won't be trading Suzuki, as long as they remain in contention, is that they aren't in a position to trade anyone from their starting lineup. Especially Suzuki, considering he may be the biggest power threat on the team outside of Pete Crow-Armstrong.

Trading Seiya Suzuki leaves a massive void in the Cubs starting lineup

It's also laughable to think that the Cubs would rely on Michael Conforto or Kevin Alcantara as suitable replacements for Suzuki in the starting lineup. It's become clear that Alcantara has fallen out of favor with the organization, and of anyone on the roster, he likely carries the strongest odd of being traded before the deadline.

As for Conforto, he's clearly having a resurgent 2026 season, but that's likely because the Cubs are being selective with how they use him. An injury to Matt Shaw has forced him into the starting lineup regularly, and it's starting to show why the Cubs need to be selective with his usage. Over his last 55 plate appearances, Conforto has a wRC+ of 92 while striking out over 30% of the time.

In other words, no, trading Suzuki and feeling comfortable with Conforto or Alcantara stepping into larger roles shouldn't exactly be a plan for the Cubs ahead of the trade deadline. That's not a scenario that makes the Cubs better this season, and that ultimately should be a large part of the consideration in any move they make.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Follow