Former Cubs outfielder made one of the worst players you'll ever see this weekend

Never known for his glove, the slugging outfielder looked lost in the field against the rival Mets.
Kyle Ross-Imagn Images

Former Chicago Cubs fan favorite Nick Castellanos was always a favorite because of the offense he provided the team after he was traded from the Detroit Tigers to the Wrigley denizens in 2019. The defense he offered was always something fans just had to swallow. That defense is now the Philadelphia Phillies' problem, and this past weekend, the outfielder once again showed how much of a problem it can be.

Castellanos's defense is once again a massive liability in 2025, with Baseball Savant putting him in the bottom one percentile in all of baseball. He's got a -9 in Fielding Run Value, and he's the perfect combination of a stone glove and a weak arm, as he has a -7 Outs Above Average rating with a -2 Arm Value. Fans might wonder how someone can achieve such abysmal ratings, considering right field is not a position known for its defense across the league. Castellanos demonstrated exactly how in the top of the sixth inning on Saturday night.

Former Chicago Cubs favorite Nick Castellanos’ latest miscue spotlights bottom tier defensive metrics in 2025

A fly ball hit to right by the New York Mets' Francisco Lindo fooled the former Chicago Cubs slugger so badly that as he chased it into the corner, he overran it to such a degree that the announcers seemed confused about how the play happened.

As Castellanos ended up in the corner of right field, the ball bounced off the wall in a spot that was pretty safely fair territory. It was, in fact, so apparent that Castellanos was nowhere near the ball that when the umpires decided to review the play after the run-scoring hit, it wasn't to see whether the ball was indeed fair or foul but whether, instead of bouncing off the wall, it went over and should have been ruled a home run.

While the gaffe was just another of those situations that Nick Castellanos demonstrated can sometimes be seen as more of a burden on the team than a blessing, the former Chicago Cubs star, who many fans would still welcome back to Wrigley with open arms (as a DH), continues to scorch teams with his bat.