Evaluating the defensive highs and lows on a projected Cubs starting lineup

The Chicago Cubs will look to have a strong defense in 2025. Last year they were well above average at multiple positions, though there were some holes too. Looking ahead, some defensive holes have been plugged and there is potential for growth at other positions. Here is a ranking of defensive positions (non-pitcher); as always, this is up for debate and subject to change with roster moves.

There are two clear positions where the Cubs are elite defensively

1.) Shortstop

• Key players: Dansby Swanson, Nico Hoerner, Vidal Bruján

There is no doubt in Dansby Swanson's abilities at shortstop. Not only is the two-time Gold Glove winner a top defensive shortstop, but he is also one of the best defenders in the game - period. Last season he was the third-best defender in baseball in FanGraphs defensive value (DEF) at 18.9 and fourth-best in Outs Above Average (OAA) at 18. He might not have the crazy range as some other defenders, but he is as sure-handed as it gets within his range. Backing him up is Nico Hoerner, who we know is a great defender, and Vidal Bruján who was a 5 DRS defender at short last year.

The shortstop position does not necessarily have the highest defensive ceiling on the team in 2025, but Swanson's extensive resume gets the bump for now. This is going with the experience.

2.) Center Field

• Key players: Pete Crow-Armstrong, Vidal Bruján

This position could honestly listed as number one as it has the highest defensive ceiling with Pete Crow-Armstrong manning the position. His speed and glove in center blew people away over a relatively small MLB sample size. That said, defense isn't like hitting. There are things for him to learn and mistakes were made as a young player in the field, but raw defensive ability usually translates.

Over 965 2/3 innings, Crow-Armstrong posted a team-leading 11 defensive runs saved (DRS) and was second in 14.1 Def with a 5.9 Ultimate Zone Rating (UZR). His defense helped make him a 2.7 fWAR player in 123 games while posting an 87 wRC+. If he plays at this level over 140+ games, and his offense continues to grow from the beginning of last year? Oh boy!