Once the Chicago White Sox kicked Joey Bart loose earlier this week, it felt inevitable that he would be on the Chicago Cubs' radar as a cheap alternative to going to the top of the market to bring back Carson Kelly.
We were correct. FanSided's Robert Murray confirms that Bart is indeed headed to the Cubs after being designated for assignment earlier this week.
Dating back to when Bart was an ascending top prospect with the San Francisco Giants, the Cubs have had interest. Admittedly, this current version of Bart is far different from the one that was expected to replace Buster Posey as the Giants' full-time catcher.
Outside of the 2024 season with the Pirates where he posted a 120 wRC+ with 13 home runs across 80 games, the bat never really followed Bart to the majors.But for what he lacks with the bat, Bart makes up for with his ability to work with a pitching staff. It was something the Pirates appreciated, and what made him a target of the White Sox at the deadline.
Joey Bart is not the elite catching prospect he once was, but the Cubs don't need him to be
First and foremost, it's important to note that Bart shouldn't be viewed as an everyday for the Cubs. With the Cubs, there's no need for him to be. He's likely to split time with Miguel Amaya, and the two might viewed as the catching tandem to open the 2027 season before one gives way to Owen Ayers. Eventually, there's an expectation that Ayers will take over as the primary catcher for the Cubs.
Arugably, with Bart now in place, there's a case to be made that Amaya could be a creative trade candidate this offseason. It seems clear that the Cubs don't trust Amaya to be their primary catcher, and with Ayers knocking on the door of being ready, the former top catching prospect could be an avenue for the Cubs to pursue cost-controlled pitching.
The larger implication from Bart's arrival is that Kelly almost certainly won't be returning to Chicago. Once Ryan Jeffers accepted the Twins' qualifying offer earlier this week, Kelly arguably become the best free-agent catcher available. He's expected to land a multi-year deal with total value that should top $20 million. Given the endless needs the Cubs have in their starting rotation, that would have been an expensive venture for Jed Hoyer and Co.
