Advertisement

The Cubs have silenced this 2024 nightmare, and it's not just because of Carson Kelly

In just 37 games, the Chicago Cubs have the best catching tandem in Major League Baseball, something hardly anyone saw coming in 2024
Nick Neumayer
Nick Neumayer

Cubbies Crib

Matt Dirksen/GettyImages

The silver linings are difficult to find in last night’s historic loss for the Chicago Cubs. After tying the game in the ninth inning, the Cubs blew the chance to win the game in the bottom of the tenth before Ryan Pressly gave up eight runs without recording a single out, practically spoon-feeding the San Francisco Giants in what turned into an embarrassing 14-5 loss. 

A big part of that ninth-inning comeback was Carson Kelly, who came in as the tying run after drawing a walk as a pinch-hitter to keep the line moving. He was a late substitution for Miguel Amaya, who had also hit a two-run homer earlier in the game.

While many questions remain about the roster, the catcher position has been the Cubs’ biggest source of stability.

Looking back to 2024, catcher was one of the weakest links of the roster. Yan Gomes was unable to replicate his solid 2023 campaign and was released after 34 games. Amaya had yet to prove himself as a reliable piece of the future and many were starting to question whether he ever would. 

Come July 7, Amaya debuted a new swing with no leg kick. From that point on, he was a completely different hitter, finishing the season with a .282 batting average and a very respectable .799 OPS. He’s shown no signs of slowing down, already with three home runs to his name and an OPS+ of 111.

After being signed primarily as a defensive-minded backup catcher for the 2025 season, Kelly is putting up numbers that would make even Barry Bonds turn his head. In just 21 games, Kelly has eight home runs to his name along with an absurd OPS of 1.306. Kelly even hit for the cycle on March 31 against the Athletics.

After making a swing change over the offseason, Kelly is showing no signs of slowing down, a surprise to be sure, but a welcome one for the Cubs.

The Cubs ranked 18th in positional WAR at the catcher position in 2024 with 1.6 wins above replacement level. The Cubs have matched that total in 2025, only needing 37 games to do so to lead Major League Baseball at that position. 

The Cubs currently boast a three-game lead in the division over the Milwaukee Brewers, the largest divisional lead in MLB. The Cubs will continue to rely on Kelly and Amaya to stay hot if they want to keep building on it.

Nick Neumayer

Nick Neumayer

Nick joins FanSided with a lifetime of experience following Chicago sports, joining Cubbies Crib in 2025. He previously covered the Loyola Ramblers men's basketball team for NBC Sports Chicago as a beat writer, reporting on regular season, NCAA Tournament and NIT games across a three year span. Nick graduated in May of 2025 with a bachelor's degree in multimedia journalism from Loyola University Chicago and will be pursuing his master's in sports media at the Medill School of Journalism at Northwestern University in the fall.