Skip to main content

Cubs' push for Clay Holmes reunion is only part of a much bigger offseason puzzle

Would it be good? Yes. Would it be enough? Not even close.
ByNick Deeds
Aug 25, 2026; Phoenix, Arizona, USA; Chicago Cubs pitcher Clay Holmes against the Arizona Diamondbacks at Chase Field. Mandatory Credit: Mark J. Rebilas-Imagn Images
Aug 25, 2026; Phoenix, Arizona, USA; Chicago Cubs pitcher Clay Holmes against the Arizona Diamondbacks at Chase Field. Mandatory Credit: Mark J. Rebilas-Imagn Images | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

The Chicago Cubs have a ton of work to do in their rotation this offseason, and one of the more obvious places to begin is with the veteran that the Cubs shipped top prospect Jefferson Rojas to Queens in order to bring into the fold at the trade deadline this past summer. It shouldn't be a surprise, then, that GM Carter Hawkins acknowledged at the GM Meetings that Holmes is still on the Cubs' radar for 2027.

The reasons to pursue Clay Holmes aren't much different now than they were a few months ago. The veteran is a groundball machine, with a 60.7% grounder rate in 2026 to go along with his career mark of 62.3%. That makes him one of the best in the sport at keeping the ball on the ground, which is a very attractive trait for a team like the Cubs that enjoys elite defense from Dansby Swanson, Nico Hoerner, and Alex Bregman around the infield.

While Holmes has always looked like a brilliant fit in Chicago on paper, the results down the stretch this year were a little more mixed. His 4.25 ERA in a Cubs uniform was exactly league average, but a closer look reminds fans that he enjoyed an utterly dominant August (1.55 ERA in four starts) but struggled badly in September with 20 runs (18 earned) allowed in 19 2/3 frames that month.

Some of those struggles can surely be chalked up to the loss of Dansby Swanson, who missed 28 games late in the year due to an oblique injury. Not all of Holmes's poor performance can be excused by downgraded defense, however. He issues as many walks (15) as strikeouts in September, which is not exactly a recipe for success.

Clay Holmes is still a good fit for the Cubs... but shouldn't be counted on as an ace

That can be written off as one poor month to some extent, but a look at the longer-term trend lines makes it clear that the Cubs can't rely on Holmes to be the ace he looked like he might be back in August. Since becoming a starter in 2025, Holmes has a strikeout minus walk percentage of just 8.7%. Only four starters with 200 or more innings over the last two years have numbers lower than Holmes: Walker Buehler, Miles Mikolas, Andre Pallante, and Randy Vasquez.

That's not great company to keep, although only Pallante in that group can compare to Holmes's elite groundball numbers. Regardless, Holmes's lack of strikeouts and occasional bouts of wildness make him tough to rely on as a surefire Game 1 starter in a playoff game. Perhaps Justin Steele can be that guy again, but it would be a tough sell to fans considering he didn't even make the playoff roster in 2026 thanks to his long layoff, which will surely impact his workload next season.

The good news for Cubs fans, then, is that it doesn't seem likely that the Cubs are focusing on Holmes as their top addition for the winter. While Tarik Skubal seems to be pretty much off the table, there's some smoke surrounding young lefty Trevor Rogers as a potential front-end option. Perhaps Freddy Peralta or a trade candidate like Reid Detmers or George Kirby could find their way to Chicago as well, this winter. Any of those guys would make Holmes look like an exciting secondary addition.

Add us as a preferred source on Google