Cubs' handling of Kevin Alcantara provides harsh reality for his future

Kevin Alcántara's rapidly devolving situation with the Chicago Cubs represents an old-fashioned catch-22: The team isn't giving him enough playing time in the big leagues to improve his game, but his game isn't good enough right now to justify more playing time.

Following an inexplicable baserunning error on Sunday Night Baseball, the Cubs demoted their longtime top prospect once again, sending him back to Triple-A Iowa to make room on the active roster for Matt Shaw. It was an obvious decision given his lack of presence on the roster, but also a frustrating end to another frustratingly short cup of coffee in Chicago.

With so much uncertainty surrounding the organization's future, kicking the can down the road a little further is the safe call to make. However, we've been given no reason to expect that Alcántara will take on a bigger role in the years to come.

Cubs can't keep pulling the plug on Kevin Alcántara, lest they ruin his future

This July will mark the five-year anniversary of Alcántara's arrival to the Cubs, having come over as the centerpiece in the Anthony Rizzo trade. That's a lot of time to develop and evaluate a player, and yet it feels like we're no closer to knowing what his future holds than we were back in 2021.

He's clearly moved beyond the need for Triple-A seasoning; he's hitting .248/.342/.565 with 15 home runs in 42 games at that level this year. Sure, he's still striking out too much, but the 23-year-old has had little issue making mincemeat of the pitchers he's seen in 2026.

Yet he's only received 32 total MLB plate appearances across the past three seasons, hitting .200/.250/.200 in that time. The Cubs have just never given him the leeway to actually figure out if he has what it takes to be a full-time outfielder in the big leagues.

That's a problem for multiple reasons. Alcántara only has one minor-league option remaining, meaning that the team will soon have to keep him in the big leagues in order to keep him around on the 40-man roster.

On the same note, with both Ian Happ and Seiya Suzuki ticketed for free agency this upcoming offseason, it'd really behoove the Cubs to figure out if Alcántara can be trusted with one of the corner outfield spots adjacent to Pete Crow-Armstrong. It'd be nice to enter the winter knowing that he's capable of being a starter (or if he's nothing more than a fourth outfielder).

Likewise, if the team plans to use him as trade ammunition at the deadline, other teams will surely want to see him audition against MLB pitchers. His struggles at the top level have been so spread out that it's nearly impossible to draw any conclusions about The Jaguar's big-league bona fides.

With the whole team struggling, the obvious answer is to get Alcántara back to Chicago and let him play at least a few times per week. He's fallen so far out of favor with the coaching staff, though, that it's hard to imagine Craig Counsell willingly inserting him back into the lineup.

With the trade deadline looming, we're likely to get an answer (or a prelude to an answer) to the Alcántara dilemma soon enough. Barring a miracle, it likely won't be a very satisfying one.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Follow