The starting pitching market has started to move, and quickly, with both Dustin May and Sonny Gray off the board. While the Chicago Cubs have yet to get in on the action in any meaningful way, it'd be wrong to assume they aren't doing anything. Their focus at the moment appears to be on Japanese star Kaima Taira, whom they keep getting connected to as one of nine teams involved in his market. Though indications are that they'll be less aggressive until after the lockout, Taira's posting period forces them to act now if they want to get him in the door.
For many reasons, the 5-foot-8 fireballer makes a lot of sense on the North Side. He'd add much-needed velocity to a rotation that needs swing-and-miss; he's coming off a season in which he posted a 1.36 ERA and 2.28 FIP in 146 innings, and he's on the younger side at just 27 years old. Signing him also sustains the Cubs' footprint in Japan, with Seiya Suzuki and Shota Imanaga unlikely to return. Most importantly for the front office, though, his high upside will come cheaper than anyone at the upper tiers of the market, with a projected deal around five years, $72.5 million.
All those reasons and more are why ESPN recently predicted that the Cubs will be the ultimate winner of the Taira sweepstakes in their recent offseason predictions roundup. However, they went one step further, also throwing in Clay Holmes as one of their offseason prizes. It's no secret that the team has been interested in exploring reunions with Holmes and David Peterson, given how well their groundball-heavy profiles fit their core, so bringing back the righty wouldn't be a surprise.
Getting those two in the door would do a lot to rebuild a pitching staff left wide open by injuries and free agency. Yet, the reason why those two were picked by ESPN doesn't sit well with where the Cubs should be spending. It all comes down to the fact that the team hasn't inked a nine-figure deal for a starter since Yu Darvish and, similarly, isn't keen on signing players with the qualifying offer. They're probably even less likely to do the latter after going over the luxury tax last year.
Chicago needs to do more than just get Taira and Holmes to improve on last year, and if not just Tarik Skubal, but Freddy Peralta, Michael King, and Trevor Rogers end up out of their range, that'd be a frustrating reality. They still require at least one more surefire starter, ideally an ace. Each of the higher-end options has warts, but just paying one of them would be the most straightforward way to address their needs using the money that's come off the books.
Kaima Taira and Clay Holmes can't be relied on to provide enough innings or impact
Both Taira and Holmes also have concerns that require a bit more insurance. For as good as the former's stuff is, his experience as a starter is limited. Aside from 2023 and 2026, he's primarily been a reliever, creating questions about just how much of a workload he can provide in a 162-game season. Holmes, meanwhile, didn't quite live up to expectations in a Cubs uniform despite a strong start, posting a 4.25 ERA and 4.09 FIP after being traded over. Factor in that Justin Steele is coming off nearly two lost seasons and that Edward Cabrera had a disastrous debut, and it's clear much more depth is required.
In the end, a trade might be the move to find impact, though that's become much harder in the wake of the Mariners' trade for Maikel Garcia. The Cubs lined up well as a partner to land one of their young starters, but that's not happening after they shipped off Bryce Miller. Reid Detmers is still an option, but the Angels are going to want a king's ransom for him. A deal with the Rangers could make sense too, even if no one option is a perfect fit.
However they do it, this is a Cubs team that cannot enter next year without adding many more innings, and that's if they brought in Taira and Holmes.
