Skip to main content

Cubs forced to abandon one trade idea after Mariners put definitive end to one rumor

And that puts this trade fit to bed.
ByJordan Campbell
Texas Rangers v Seattle Mariners
Texas Rangers v Seattle Mariners | Jack Compton/GettyImages

At first blush, once the Seattle Mariners traded starting pitcher Bryce Miller to the Kansas Cit Royals on Wednesday, it felt like they were no longer a trade fit for the Chicago Cubs. The Mariners have been entertaining the idea of trading pitching for offense over the past two years, and they finally found a deal that works, landing third baseman Maikel Garcia from Kansas City.

In that trade, the Mariners found an infield bat, and used a starting pitcher to push the deal across the finish the line. In other words, it is hard to imagine that they would have much interest in a deal with the Cubs centered around Matt Shaw.

Nonetheless, Mariners president of baseball operations Jared Dipoto has slammed the door shut on the idea of Seattle trading another starting pitcher this offseason. After the trade on Wednesday, Dipoto said there is "zero chance" the Mariners trade another starting pitcher from their rotation this offseason.

The Mariners' surplus of pitching has been figured out since the deadline. Seattle traded Luis Castillo to the White Sox at the deadline, and beyond trading Miller to the Royals, they also traded right-handed pitcher Logan Evans.

Cubs no longer have an ideal trade partner in the Seattle Mariners

Specific to the Cubs, they were connected to Mariners' pitchers Logan Gilbert and Emerson Hancock at the deadline. Gilbert would have fit the bill of being the ace of the Cubs' rotation in 2027, and is under control for one more season. Hancock, meanwhile, likely would have slid closer to the bottom of the rotation, but would have arrived with an additional four years of control.

It would have been difficult for the Cubs to match what the Mariners found in their deal with the Royals. While a case could be made that Shaw has a higher ceiling than Garcia, there's an added level of expectation the Mariners can count on with Garcia, who is also under a team-friendly contract through the 2030 season. With the Mariners having their sights on returning to contention in 2027, it makes sense why they gambled on what they know in Garcia instead of what they might be getting if Shaw figures things out.

Under the right circumstance, Shaw is is a valuable trade chip that the Cubs have to offer in a deal for a cost-controlled starting pitcher. Considering the free-agent market for pitching continues to be expensive, perhaps the trade route is where the Cubs go before the lockout in December.

Add us as a preferred source on Google