I probably don't need to remind you of the Zac Gallen fiasco from a year ago, when a certain reporter with a questionable track record stated that the right-hander had signed with the Chicago Cubs just before the Winter Meetings. Of course, that nonexistent deal fell through, since the 2023 All-Star was actually getting married at the time that the report initially came out.
That supposed agreement with the Cubs was supposed to pay Gallen an average of $22 million per year over several seasons; he wound up having to settle for a one-year deal worth that same salary, undoubtedly affected by his poor 2025 season and the weight of the qualifying offer he was attached to.
The good news is that Gallen has no such QO-related burden to deal with this time around. The bad news is that his 2026 effort was even worse than the year before. He no longer resembles anything close to the pitcher who finished in the top 10 in NL Cy Young voting three times in a four-year span (2020-23).
And yet, the Cubs may be interested in him again. For real this time.
Zac Gallen is no longer reliable enough to be a priority for Cubs in free agency
According to The Athletic's Sahadev Sharma, the Cubs might be inclined to revisit talks with the 31-year-old starter this offseason. He stopped short of concretely reporting interest between both sides, but Sharma did point to the fact that the organization monitored Gallen's market up until the point he re-signed with the Diamondbacks just before the start of spring training.
Your mileage will vary on what to make of this connection; some may see this as nothing more than a part of a leave-no-stone-unturned search for pitching this offseason, while others might buy into the obvious relationship the Cubs have cultivated with the right-hander over the past year. For my part, I'd like to see Gallen come to Chicago, but only as a pure depth play. He's a massive bounce-back candidate after a few down seasons, but this team needs far more certainty in the rotation than he currently provides.
Beyond the really ugly surface results (6.07 ERA, 5.34 FIP, -0.1 fWAR) and somehow-even-worse metrics (bottom-10 percentile finishes in whiff rate, strikeout rate, barrel rate, and hard-hit rate), perhaps the worst thing that happened to Gallen in 2026 is that his health finally betrayed him. After making at least 28 starts and averaging 183.5 innings between 2022-25, he finished with 20 and 105⅓ this year. He missed two months over the summer while tending to elbow inflammation, which is not the kind of injury you want a 31-year-old pitcher with huge mileage on his arm to be dealing with.
The upside that made him one of the National League's premier starters for so long is certainly still in there, and his ability to eat tons of innings at least gives him a high floor in terms of bang for your buck. But if the Cubs want to feel confident about their pitching staff heading into next year, signing Gallen has to be just one small part of a much larger plan.
