Skip to main content

Carson Kelly’s Cubs future sealed by Ryan Jeffers’ surprise qualifying offer decision

Just like that, the free-agent catcher market gets a big shake-up.
ByJake Misener
Brace Hemmelgarn/Minnesota Twins/GettyImages

Two players accepted the qualifying offer on Tuesday afternoon. David Bednar will return to the New York Yankees' bullpen in 2027 after accepting and, on a far more suprising note, the Minnesota Twins will have Ryan Jeffers back behind the dish next year, as well.

Jeffers was widely viewed as the top catcher on this winter's free agent class (Spotrac projected a three-year, $40 million offer and MLB Trade Rumors was even more lucrative at four years, $75 million), but instead will return to the Twin Cities.

For several years now, he's been the model of consistency behind the plate for the Twins. Since the start of the 2023 season, he carries a 116 OPS+ and, this season in particular, was one of the top offensive catchers in the game. Jeffers isn't particularly well-regarded on the defensive side of things, but he looked to be in the midst of a huge breakout campaign at the plate in 2026 before an injury slowed him considerably.

The Chicago Cubs were never seen as a serious player for him on the market, so why are we so focused on this decision? Well, because Carson Kelly's free-agent stock just jumped. You can make the case that he's now the clear-cut best catching option on the market and nobody is poised to capitalize on Jeffers' choice to accept the QO quite as much as Kelly.

Cubs are prepared to roll with Miguel Amaya, Owen Ayers in 2027

Sure, the Cubs would like to have Kelly back. He was a huge success for the team during his two-year stint on the North Side, but were never going to give him what he was going to command (even before removing Jeffers from the equation) on the open market in a weak free-agent class.

Instead, 2027 looks to be the year Miguel Amaya finally ascends to the top of the depth chart and, behind him, catching prospect Owen Ayers looks to be the #2. His meteoric rise through the system has him in prime position to back up Amaya next season and, while we might see some veteran depth added on low-dollar or minor-league deals this winter, Kelly's likely asking price was (and now definitely is) too rich for the Cubs' blood.

Add us as a preferred source on Google