Caleb Kilian's Phillies stint is off to brutal start Cubs know all too well

Once upon a time, Caleb Kilian was considered a good-enough prospect to be one of the centerpieces in a trade deadline blockbuster for 2016 NL MVP Kris Bryant. Alongside Alexander Canario (who is currently struggling in the NPB in Japan), the right-hander was one of the most exciting young talents that the Chicago Cubs acquired during that 2021 fire sale.

Unfortunately, the deal flamed out in rather sad fashion. Both Canario and Kilian were let go from the organization in recent years, failing to ever make a mark in Chicago in their limited exposure to the major leagues.

However, much like Canario getting one last shot in Pittsburgh before having to settle for an international contact, the Giants reunited with Kilian in hopes they could spark some of his old magic in a familiar location. For the most part, the idea worked; the right-hander converted seamlessly to the bullpen, pitching to a 4.26 ERA and 3.58 FIP while striking out 27.5% of the hitters he faced.

That success once again turned him into a valuable trade chip this summer. And once again, his new team is finding out the difficult reality that comes attached to Kilian's talent.

Caleb Kilian's latest injury adds another painful chapter to the legacy of the ill-fated Kris Bryant trade

Kilian was traded to the Philadelphia Phillies alongside Luis Arraez, with the intention that he'd serve as the de facto replacement for another former Cubs reliever, Brad Keller, who is out for the season following elbow surgery. He then proceeded to get lit up by the Nationals in his second appearance with the Phillies and has recorded a 13.50 ERA across four outings.

In even worse news, he's heading back to the IL with an oblique strain, having injured his ribs on the final pitch of a 7-6 victory over the Blue Jays this past weekend. There's no timeline that's been offered for his recovery, but Grade 1 oblique strains usually take about four-to-six weeks to overcome, with anything more severe likely knocking him out for the rest of 2026.

This isn't a new development for the right-hander either. Kilian dealt with his fair share of injuries during his time with the Cubs, most notably a shoulder strain in 2024 that cost him the entire first half. He only tossed 27.1 MLB innings in Chicago, due in part to the fact that he struggled to stay on the field for extended stretches.

Thus is the legacy of that Bryant trade. Canario's strikeout problems aside, the litany of injuries that have since sapped Bryant and Kilian's talent have effectively rendered the deal a mere footnote at the end of the Cubs' last championship window.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Follow