A reunion with a former Cubs trade deadline hit is the last thing this team needs

2026 has been a roller coaster for Chicago Cubs fans, with the highs of two 10-game win streaks giving way to a brutal slump over the past few weeks. Between a power outage in the lineup and brutal injuries up and down the pitching staff, there's not been a lot going right on the north side lately. That's caused fans to look for ways to shake up the team that go beyond the returns of Edward Cabrera and Matthew Boyd.

Meanwhile, an old friend has suddenly become available. The Padres recently made the decision to cut veteran Nick Castellanos from their roster just 39 games into his career with the Friars. Cubs fans surely remember Castellanos as the spark plug that helped a hobbled Cubs offense stay afloat after the trade deadline in 2019, though he wasn't able to stop a September collapse. Unfortunately, there's little reason aside from nostalgia to think he could help the Cubs out of their current rut either.

Castellanos's 51 games as a member of the Cubs were the stuff of legend, as he slashed a sensational .321/.356/.646 with 16 homers and 21 doubles in just 225 trips to the plate for Chicago after being acquired from the Tigers in exchange for righties Alex Lange and Paul Richan. The surprising decision to let Castellanos walk to the division rival Reds that offseason stuck in the craw of Cubs fans for years after the fact, but a reunion now would do the team no favors.

The Cubs already have a veteran corner outfielder on the bench who offers more than Nick Castellanos

Now 34 years old, Castellanos is simply no longer the hitter he once was. He's had a couple of big seasons since leaving Chicago that earned him All-Star nods and down-ballot MVP votes, but for much of that time he's been a roughly average hitter overall. More recently, his bumpy Phillies tenure (which Castellanos himself recently reflected on with the Dan Gelston of the Associated Press) came to a close this year due to discord between him and recently fired manager Rob Thomson.

While Castellanos surely hoped that getting away from Philadelphia would help revitalize his career, his brief tenure in San Diego did just the opposite. Across 122 plate appearances, Castellanos hit just .191/.221/.339 with a 27.9 percent strikeout rate. A .560 OPS would be difficult to stomach even for an elite defensive player in a bench role, but it's completely unplayable for a DH and corner bat like Castellanos.

As if that terrible production wasn't reason enough to pass on Castellanos as part of this team's bench mix, the club already has a veteran corner bat and DH who is flourishing in the part-time role he's been given. Michael Conforto has been one of the team's biggest bright spots this year, with five more extra-base hits in his first 39 games as a Cub than Castellanos had during his own 39-game tenure with the Padres.

Even if Castellanos was putting up halfway decent numbers (which he most certainly did not do with the Padres), Conforto is playing well enough in the exact sort of role Castellanos would be looking to fill with this team that it would be hard to justify rostering him. Perhaps an argument could be made to send Moises Ballesteros or Kevin Alcantara to Iowa for more regular at-bats, but even someone like Triple-A's Chas McCormick would likely be a better fit for this roster.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Follow