Skip to main content

3 wildly underwhelming pitchers Cubs could bring in to bolster rotation

Another winter of avoiding high-dollar arms could lead to a familiar outcome in 2027.
ByJake Misener
Geoff Stellfox/GettyImages

Under Jed Hoyer, the Chicago Cubs have avoided the top (or, really, anywhere near the top) of the free-agent starting pitching market like the plague. That approach has proven costly in each of the last two years, with rotation weakness taking center stage in the playoffs, so one would think we might see a different gameplan this time around.

We know the Cubs are out on the belle of the ball this winter, Tarik Skubal, there are plenty of other quality arms available, including Michael King, Adrian Morejon, Trevor Rogers, Freddy Peralta and more. Frankly, I don't have reason to believe they'll do what it takes to get one of those pitchers, either.

So to bring out my favorite analogy when it comes to Cubs' roster building. We're back in the early 2000s, digging through the discount DVD bins at Wal-Mart, hoping and praying we find a hidden gem for $5... except this time, it's finding cheap starting pitchers to plug holes in the starting rotation. Fun.

3 pitchers the Cubs could target in free agency looking to save a dime

Sean Newcomb

Sean Newcomb is not a starting pitcher. Or, at least, he hasn't shown the ability to be a reliable one in a long, long time. The veteran left-hander had a very nice 2026 season with the Chicago White Sox and did start six games, but also made 54 relief appearances. It's clear that's the role he should play at this point in his career, but in a market where starters are commanding bigger and bigger contracts each winter, teams are more likely than ever to get weird and try some stuff.

Viewing Newcomb, who hasn't pitched 100 innings in a season since 2018, as a starter would certainly be a decision - and one that feels highly likely to blow up in your face. He's battled command and consistency issues in his career and under no circumstances can he be viewed as a rotation 'answer'. A roll-of-the-dice cherry on top of an otherwise impressive rotation haul? Sure. But nothing more.

Kyle Freeland

There's nothing like looking to a player who's spent his entire career with the Colorado Rockies to be a rotation solution. Coming off a 6.65 ERA in 2026, Kyle Freeland, like most Rockies pitchers, has always been better on the road than at home, but not by a margin that makes you feel like a change of scenery will be a real difference-maker for him.

A career 4.62 ERA isn't anything to write home about. He does limit walks incredibly well, which is a win, but doesn't do either of the two things the Cubs prioritize well: induce ground balls and strike batters out. A 17.6 percent K rate last year ranked in the bottom 15 percent of pitchers and his ground-ball rate left much to be desired. Freeland is back-end depth, at best, but could even end up on a minor-league deal somewhere.

Frankie Montas

Okay, okay. There is some upside on this list if recent reports are to be believed. Frankie Montas threw for clubs this month and turned some heads - a surprise given he hasn't pitched in an MLB game since Aug. 2025 and hasn't been a quality rotation piece since 2022.

But, again, the Cubs need more than upside. A lot more. That doesn't mean Hoyer won't go for another low-cost, high-risk move, because he's got a history of taking that path. Montas was sitting upper-90s with his heater in that bullpen session and we all know the Cubs could use some more velo. He was once viewed as an arm on the rise. Will he get a chance to re-establish himself in Chicago?

Add us as a preferred source on Google