Ranking the 5 biggest stars the Cubs traded away over the years

As the trade deadline approaches, let’s look back at the biggest stars the Chicago Cubs have sent packing over the years.

As Willson Contreras familiarizes himself with the real estate market in San Diego, it might be a good time to look at other great Cubs the team has traded away over the years. These aren’t the worst trades the Cubs have made, but rather trades involving players who established themselves as stars with the Cubs. In this post, the numbers in parentheses are WAR totals are from Fangraphs, and reflect each player’s WAR with the Cubs.

#5: 1981 – RHP Rick Reuschel (47.0) to the New York Yankees for RHP Doug Bird (1.1) and RHP Mike Griffin (0.7)

Even by the Cubs’ historical standards, the 1981 squad was a bad one. They wouldn’t get their tenth win until May 30. Rick Reuschel would pitch his last game for this ill-chosen assortment of players on June 10. Two days later, on the same day the players decided to strike, the Cubs sent Reuschel east for $400,000 of George Steinbrenner’s cash and two guys. The team tried to make this sound like smart roster development, but it was mainly a salary dump.

Cubs fans were outraged, and not without reason; a franchise icon had just been sent to a team powered by the fires of hell. But spare a thought for Doug Bird, who through no fault of his own wound up at the business end of the fans’ ire. He actually had a decent season for the Cubs in the second half of 1981’s ridiculous split schedule, though he cratered the following year.

After missing the 1982 season because of rotator cuff surgery, Reuschel would return to the Cubs and pitch in limited duty for the next two seasons. He would rejuvenate his career in Pittsburgh, before moving on to San Francisco and pitching well enough to earn Cy Young consideration at age 40. He’s a remarkable and too often overlooked pitcher.

#2: 2005 – RF Sammy Sosa (60.7) to the Baltimore Orioles for 2B Mike Fontenot (4.1), UT Jerry Hairston (1.7), and RHP Dave Crouthers (minors)

“The whole persona of him smiling, well, he turned into a pretty big piece of crap.” “If you create a Frankenstein monster, you can’t be real surprised if he eats the village.”

Reuschel, Jenkins, Williams, Santo … you’d have to hire a very good P.I. to uncover a Cubs fan that has much bad to say about any of those guys. Not so for Sammy Sosa, who hopped aboard Icarus Airlines without reading the fine print. Those quotes above are from this long 2005 ESPN piece on the rise and (mostly) fall of Sammy Sosa.

The identity of the Cub who smashed Sosa’s infamous boombox on the last day of the 2004 season remains a secret: Ryan Dempster probably knows, but he’s not saying. What isn’t a secret is that by 2004 many people throughout the Cubs organization were beginning to conclude that Sosa’s costs exceeded his benefits. The very length of the ESPN story speaks to the volume of adverse information numerous Cubs sources were willing – indeed eager – to unload.

That said, Sosa was a very productive player. Baseball players are paid to produce wins, and Sosa produced 60, a Hall of Fame-ish total. There’s a good chance his plaque would be in there now, and that the ESPN piece never would have been written, if not for the PED scandal. Sosa never admitted using them; the only public evidence linking him to PEDs is one leaked test result from 2003. Whatever one thinks of Sosa, hammering him while ignoring the forces that made him possible seems short-sighted at best. However, even if he didn’t use, Sosa still did plenty to author his own demise; it isn’t hard to see why the franchise treats him like a cat treats a bath.

Given the unfavorable context in which the trade took place, the Cubs’ return wasn’t that bad. Both Fontenot and Hairston would provide some help to the roster, though each was generally overmatched as a lineup regular. Crouthers – a promising young arm – would never reach The Show, done in by the yips.  There are regions of the distant universe that we understand better than regions of the human mind. Credit to Crouthers for being open about his struggles; the worst thing about anxiety is thinking it happens to no one else.

#1: 1973 – 3B Ron Santo (71.9) to the Chicago White Sox for RHP Steve Stone (4.5), LHP Ken Frailing (2.0), C Steve Swisher (0.2), and LHP Jim Kremmel (0.0)

Don’t you miss the good old days of baseball labor strife? (Oh … right.) Anyway, as the result of the 1972 players’ strike, MLB agreed to the 10-5 rule, which allows players who have been in the majors for ten years and at least five with the same team to veto a proposed trade. Santo was the first player to invoke the rule, vetoing a trade to the Angels and thus denying thousands of Chicago area kids the opportunity to buy Andy Hassler jerseys.

Santo wanted to stay in Chicago, so he travelled down I-94 to Old Comiskey in exchange for the swag listed above. It was a sad end to an outstanding career. Santo slashed .221/.293/.299, leading him to suffer his only negative WAR season. The Cubs got three solid seasons (and a future broadcasting gig) from Steve Stone, whose best years still lay ahead of him in Baltimore. And nominative determinists out there (you know who you are) can’t help but love Steve Swisher, who struck out a healthy seven percent more than the league during his career.

Cubs: Looking at some honorable mention candidates

As the Cubs first (OK, only) World Series dynasty began to fray at the edges, owner Charles Murphy started flinging toys out of the pram, trading two-thirds of the legendary double play combination (the other third, Frank Chance, was waived at the end of the 1912 season). First to be traded was SS Joe Tinker (46.6) after the 1912 season to the Cincinnati Reds for five guys (no, not the hamburger people), only one of whom would make a significant impact with the Cubs: aging righty Bert Humphries.

Tinker would return to the Cubs after jumping to the Chicago Whales of the Federal League. He was one of several players the Cubs bought from the Whales when they went belly up. I’m in town all week folks, try the plankton.

Next to go was 2B Johnny Evers (41.0), traded to the Boston Braves after the 1913 season. Evers had a vitriolic fight with Murphy, claiming that Murphy had breached a five-year contract they had signed at the beginning of the 1913 season, and refused to report.

The trade had the aroma of retaliation. The Braves were a joke of a franchise; their last winning season had been in 1902. But with the looming threat of the new Federal League, star players had power, and Evers used it. Fearing he would jump to the new league, the National League owners nullified the trade, effectively making Evers a free agent. Consequently, and predictably, he became baseball’s highest paid player in 1914, giving owners an object lesson in the dangers of free agency. More surprisingly, he went ahead and signed with the Braves.

Want your voice heard? Join the Cubbies Crib team!

Write for us!

And from here, the story goes all Frank Capra on us. Named captain of the team, the aging Evers spearheaded one of the most unlikely pennant drives in baseball history, leading the “Miracle Braves” to the franchise’s first World Series victory. Evers was named NL MVP in just the award’s third season of existence. The numbers don’t quite back it up, but only the coldest of sabermetric hearts could have advocated for any other result.