Chicago Cubs: Despite closer woes, team made the right call on Wade Davis

Wade Davis / Chicago Cubs (Photo by Matthew Stockman/Getty Images)
Wade Davis / Chicago Cubs (Photo by Matthew Stockman/Getty Images)
2 of 3
Next
Wade Davis/ Chicago Cubs (Photo by Jonathan Daniel/Getty Images)
Wade Davis/ Chicago Cubs (Photo by Jonathan Daniel/Getty Images) /

Right-hander Wade Davis succeeded Aroldis Chapman as Chicago Cubs closer in 2017, but after just one year, the team moved on from the veteran hurler.

Without the midseason acquisition of Aroldis Chapman in 2016, perhaps we’re still counting the years – and generations – since the Chicago Cubs won the World Series. The flame-throwing left-hander didn’t come without his share of controversy, but his impact on the club is incontrovertible.

Manager Joe Maddon squeezed every last drop out of Chapman’s left arm, especially in the postseason. But once the confetti had fallen and the parade concluded, his former club, the New York Yankees, swooped in with a massive five-year, $86 million deal to bring him back into the fold.

His departure left a hole at the back end of Chicago’s bullpen. Prior to Chapman, right-hander Hector Rondon filled the role admirably, but he never seemed to profile as the guy come the ninth inning, at least not to the Cubs brass.

So, knowing they had to find a solution if they had any hopes of repeating as World Series champions in 2017. The answer? A trade for former Kansas City Royals standout Wade Davis, who was entering his final year of team control.

Theo Epstein sent slugging outfielder Jorge Soler to the Royals in the deal, shoring up the ninth inning while pulling from a position of strength in the outfield.

Wade Davis / Chicago Cubs (Photo by Matthew Stockman/Getty Images)
Wade Davis / Chicago Cubs (Photo by Matthew Stockman/Getty Images) /

Chicago Cubs: The former closer has fallen on hard times in Colorado

Davis lived up to the hype in Chicago, notching 32 saves – the most by a Cubs closer in a single season since Kevin Gregg‘s 33 in 2011. He ran off an impressive stretch to open the year, making 31 appearances, finishing 29 games and working to a 1.80 ERA en route to an All-Star nod.

His work wasn’t always clean – but somehow, he always got the job done when handed the ball. Of course, the moment that stands out most when looking back at his year on the North Side is his game-ending strikeout of Bryce Harper to close out the tumultuous final game of the NLDS in Washington.

The right-hander turned his impressive campaign into a successful foray into free agency. Davis inked a three-year, $52 million deal with the Colorado Rockies which, remains one of the highest AAV deals ever given to a reliever. The 34-year-old enters the final year of that contract with the highest AAV amongst big league relievers at $17.33 million.

To say the least, Davis hasn’t lived up to that salary during his two seasons in Colorado. He’s made 119 appearances – albeit, they haven’t been of the quality variety. Davis has limped to a 5.92 ERA and 1.380 WHIP. Although his 4.40 FIP suggests he’s been the victim of at least some bad luck and his numbers are largely inflated by a horrendous 2019 showing.

After leading the league with 63 games finished and 43 saves in 2018, the wheels completely fell off last year. He made 50 appearances, but got shelled to the tune of an 8.65 ERA (5.56 FIP) – fueled, at least in part, by an inflated walk and hit rate (6.1 BB/9) and (10.8 H/9).

Wade Davis / Chicago Cubs (Photo by Jonathan Daniel/Getty Images)
Wade Davis / Chicago Cubs (Photo by Jonathan Daniel/Getty Images) /

Chicago Cubs: Things could be even worse with Davis

You can expect at least some degree of a bounceback in 2020, but unless he somehow reverts back to his All-Star form of the past, the Rockies are burning money at this point. Davis has shown that he’s not the same guy he once was – and, regardless of what we might think of Chicago’s late-inning situation, having Davis in tow would have handicapped the Cubs even more.

More from Cubbies Crib

After Davis signed with Colorado, Epstein turned to former Los Angeles standout setup man Brandon Morrow. The right-hander started off hot, pitching to a 1.47 ERA in 35 appearances before hitting the shelf. Unfortunately, to this point he is yet to return – although he returned to the organization via a minor league deal this winter in hopes of still making a comeback.

His injuries, paired with inconsistencies in the bullpen last year, prompted Epstein to go out and ink Craig Kimbrel to a three-year, $43 million deal last summer. Of course, he struggled a great deal and heading into 2020, remains a big question mark in the Chicago bullpen.

But the Cubs are hoping that with a normal offseason (although the ongoing COVID-19 pandemic, that’s been cast into question, as well) – Kimbrel can return to form. Chicago had pieces in place to replace Davis when he left: Pedro Strop, Rondon, Morrow and others. The simple truth is this: Epstein saw the writing on the wall three years ago and made the right call.

Next. Evaluating Marmol's legacy with the Chicago Cubs. dark

Today’s situation, one where the bullpen is being pieced together in spring training, would only be worsened by Davis’ contract on the books. The team’s ongoing financial woes might somehow be even more problematic, as well. As great as he was in his one year with the Chicago Cubs, letting him walk in free agency was undoubtedly and irrefutably the right move.

Next