Chicago Cubs: MLB Network says Kris Bryant isn’t a Top 10 third baseman

(Photo by Quinn Harris/Getty Images)
(Photo by Quinn Harris/Getty Images)
2 of 4
Next
Kris Bryant / Chicago Cubs (Photo by Jonathan Daniel/Getty Images)
Kris Bryant / Chicago Cubs (Photo by Jonathan Daniel/Getty Images) /

For Chicago Cubs fans, this has undoubtedly been the Kris Bryant offseason. We waited until the end of January for the league arbitrator to rule on his five-year-old service time grievance and we’ve heard nothing but trade rumors since the 2019 campaign drew to a close.

But now, we know he’s under team control through 2021 and Theo Epstein can move forward with at least some degree of certainty in regards to what cards are in his hand. The downside, of course, is that while the Cubs awaited their fate, the rest of the league proceeded with their respective offseason plans.

Manager David Ross expects Bryant to be in his Opening Day lineup. After a bounceback 2019 showing where he put up a .903 OPS in 147 games, fans are high on the former first-rounder. But MLB Network thinks differently.

Their computer algorithm, dubbed ‘The Shredder’ doesn’t just think that he’s not one of the best in the game at his position. He’s not even among the top third at his position. That’s right. Kris Bryant is apparently a has-been who’s washed up and now overshadowed by his peers at the hot corner.

What a joke.

Manny Machado / San Diego Padres (Photo by Jonathan Daniel/Getty Images)
Manny Machado / San Diego Padres (Photo by Jonathan Daniel/Getty Images) /

Chicago Cubs: An interesting mix of names in the Top 10

There are some names on MLB Network’s list that make sense. Others? Not so much.

Let’s start with the back end of the rankings, numbers six through 10. Rounding out the list? San Diego Padres third baseman Manny Machado, who put up a .796 OPS last season for the Friars. I know it’s a simplistic measure, but Bryant thoroughly outpaced that performance, despite playing through some nagging injuries.

Cleveland standout Jose Ramirez clocks in at nine, behind the likes of Eugenio Suarez, Justin Turner and Josh Donaldson. So with that list of names in mind, let’s dig in a bit deeper.

According to Fangraphs, Bryant ranked higher than all of these guys in WAR last season – with the lone exception of Donaldson, who narrowly edged him by 0.1 WAR (4.9 to 4.8). Again, that’s boiling things down to one number – but it’s hard to imagine a world where Bryant isn’t more valuable than at a bare minimum, three of these guys.

In terms of wRC+, Bryant outperformed all five of these guys. Now is he an elite defender? Not at all. But he does enough to get the job done and if you’re looking at his whole body of work, there’s absolutely no doubt he’s a more valuable player than everyone I just mentioned. Sure, Donaldson had a great year in Atlanta – but he’s battled injuries, is heading into his mid-30s and lacks the versatility of a guy like Bryant.

Alex Bregman / Houston Astros (Photo by Elsa/Getty Images)
Alex Bregman / Houston Astros (Photo by Elsa/Getty Images) /

Chicago Cubs: A marred name headlines this year’s rankings

Given everything we’ve heard about the Houston Astros this offseason, it’s hard to not view someone like Alex Bregman through a very different lens than we may have prior to the league’s investigation into the team’s sign-stealing scandal.

Bregman’s initial comments after everything went public were less than savory, which does him no favors in my eyes personally. But The Shredder doesn’t care about any of that. It cares about production and, regardless of how he did it, Bregman turned in another stellar season – netting him the honors of top third baseman in baseball.

More from Cubbies Crib

He’s followed by the likes of Los Angeles Angels third baseman Anthony Rendon, who led the Washington Nationals to a World Series title in 2019, Nolan Arenado, who has seen his own name in plenty of rumors this winter, Matt Chapman – a premier defensive presence at the hot corner and Jeff McNeil of the New York Mets.

Now, here. I can admit that from a statistical standpoint, I can see Bryant being ranked behind Bregman, Rendon and Arenado – maybe even Chapman. Maybe. But there’s no way he should be lower than fourth on this list.

Why? Because McNeil didn’t even play the majority of his games at third base last season. He appeared in just 24 contests there in 2019 – as opposed to 61 games in left, 39 in right and 34 at second. He played in more games at three other positions last year and his inclusion on this list is a farce.

That’s not to take away from the year he had because McNeil was really good – and I’ve long sought him as a trade target for the Cubs as a sort of heir to Ben Zobrist at a super utility guy. He carried a .916 OPS last season, including a .384 on-base percentage. Given the Cubs’ leadoff woes, he’d check a lot of boxes – but that’s a discussion for another time. He doesn’t deserve a spot on this list, let alone the number four overall ranking.

Kris Bryant / Chicago Cubs (Photo by Denis Poroy/Getty Images)
Kris Bryant / Chicago Cubs (Photo by Denis Poroy/Getty Images) /

Chicago Cubs: Bryant has a lot riding on the upcoming season

Kris Bryant knows that he’s far from the icon he was just a few short years ago. On the heels of winning Rookie of the Year and MVP while leading the Cubs to their first World Series in over a century, he was an icon – destined be enshrined with a flag of his own on a foul pole at Wrigley Field someday.

But after a lackluster, injury-plagued 2018 campaign and declining RBI totals since that illustrious 2016 season, he’s no longer viewed in the same light. Now let’s be clear. Evaluating a player’s offensive contributions using statistics like RBI is an antiquated way of thinking that we can all hope will soon die. That hasn’t stopped folks, though, from throwing around ‘overrated’ an awful lot when talking about Bryant.

He’s spent the majority of his at-bats in the number two hole in recent years. Why isn’t he driving in more runs? Well, probably because the Cubs have lacked a true leadoff hitter since, you guessed it – 2016.

Meanwhile, he’s averaged a .390 OBP over the last three years. He plays corner outfield spots when he’s not at third and when he’s been healthy, he’s one of the top run-scorers in the league. Would you like to see him putting up those stereotypical baseball numbers? Sure. But he’s done a lot of things right and the national media and Cubs fans alike aren’t seeing that.

Next. Five prospects who will play in Chicago this season. dark

This is a huge season for Bryant. He’s just two years removed from free agency and Chicago needs to either A) see him raise his value as a trade chip or B) build a lineup around him worthy of competing for a division crown. Either way, everyone’s doubting him right now – and he’s got a chance to silence his critics in a big way this year.

Next