Chicago Cubs: Who’s to blame for the subpar first half?

(Photo by Rob Carr/Getty Images)
(Photo by Rob Carr/Getty Images)
1 of 3
Next
(Photo by Jonathan Daniel/Getty Images)
(Photo by Jonathan Daniel/Getty Images) /

The Chicago Cubs are in first, but this isn’t how we thought it would be. Up just a half-game, because the rest of the division has been just as bad. Are there fingers to be pointed?

The way the season started for the Chicago Cubs, you would think we’d be happy to be in first place in the Central. And if you didn’t know the whole story, you would be. But the Cubs have underachieved much of the season, and hold just a half-game lead over the Brewers coming out of the All-Star break. On Cubs social media, a lot of fingers are being pointed, and rightfully so. But is there truly a party to blame for the lackluster play? Depends on who you are.

There are many on Cubs’ Twitter that has taken to blaming Theo Epstein and Jed Hoyer. They feel that the Cubs had a glaring weakness in their bullpen and didn’t address it–at least not to their liking. And trading Tommy La Stella away and signing Daniel Descalso looked like a good move in the first few weeks. Now? Not so much. But while Epstein and Hoyer didn’t do much in the offseason, that was dictated from Tom Ricketts, owner of the Chicago Cubs.

(Photo by Jonathan Daniel/Getty Images)
(Photo by Jonathan Daniel/Getty Images) /

Chicago Cubs: Money was going to be tight

It was set forth by the Ricketts family that they wouldn’t be spending massive amounts of money this offseason. And he stuck to his guns. As it turned out, the Cubs may have squirreled money away to buy the remaining shares of the team still owned by the Tribune Company. Now they own the team, most of the real estate around Wrigley Field and are starting their own network, the Marquee Sports Network, next year. So while they didn’t spend this year, the money may come in faster in the coming offseason.

Now we come to the coaches. Tommy Hottovy and Anthony Iapoce weren’t Joe Maddon‘s choices. They were Epstein and the front office. It seems like this year we haven’t heard ‘as much’ about the coaches as we did last season. Chili Davis brought in a change in philosophy for situational hitting. Some of the Cubs weren’t happy with Davis, and he was fired after the season. Jim Hickey was brought over by Maddon, and he didn’t seem to do a bad job, especially with the cards he was dealt. The bullpen stayed strong through most of the season, but in the end, Hickey stepped away from the team for ‘personal reasons.’ I’ve wondered how much Epstein had to do with that, but I digress.

(Photo by Justin Berl/Getty Images)
(Photo by Justin Berl/Getty Images) /

Chicago Cubs: It’s almost impossible to pin it on one man

So then comes Maddon himself. I know as you’re reading this, you’re either on one side or the other. There aren’t too many people that sit in the middle-ground with him. Some believe he’s one of the greatest managers the Cubs have had and should be re-signed. Others want him gone due to his ‘out of the box’ approach, wacky road trips and ever-changing lineups. The Boston Red Sox have won the title with three different managers in the last 15 years, so why can’t the Cubs?

Some say he’s lost touch with his players, and can’t relate. I don’t know about all that, but it brings us to the players themselves. Maddon may make some questionable choices at times, but all he can do is expect the player to perform. And some of them aren’t cutting it. Some blame the coaches or manager first but then complain about not being able to see a game with their family because it cost too much. Part of that is because players make, well, a lot.

So shouldn’t they be on the hook for the poor play, as they’re paid millions to play a ‘kids game?’ The thing is you can point fingers at this guy or that guy. But it’s an organizational issue that has to be cleaned up. Three hitting and pitching coaches in three years. One manager for the last five. Short of Frank Chance, he’s been the best manager since. But he’s on the hot seat this year. Of course, people wanted to trade Kris Bryant because he was ‘washed up,’ his ‘best years behind him.’

Next. Cubs seem to be lacking a clubhouse leader. dark

Maybe we watch and wait to see what they’ll do. Everyone is to blame, and everyone has a chance at redemption. So in the second half, maybe just watch the Chicago Cubs and enjoy it–or not. Depending on who you point the finger at might decide if you enjoy baseball in the second half.

Next