Willson Contreras
Older than most of the young crop, Contreras has shown he’s one of the best defensive catchers in the game thanks to his absolute cannon of an arm. Offensively he’s coming along and could end up being one of the best all-around catchers in baseball.
Pros: Rumors surfaced that Contreras and the Cubs were already talking extensions in the offseason, though nothing came of it. He’s already a defensive stud and he’ll most likely be cheaper than the others.
Cons: Contreras’ inexperience is a bit of an issue. Waiting until he proves himself over time could be beneficial. This season, we’ve seen him display horrendous plate discipline at times and a lack of pop in the bat.