The Nightmare Continues
Is it possible to have a lineup in which the leader of the team bats fifth? Even a power hitting, strike-zone aware, left-handed first baseman? One that was a solid MVP candidate?
Yes. Yes, it is. And it is beautiful.
Think about it. Anthony Rizzo bats fifth, after Schwarber and Bryant. Each provides protection for the other. All can hit for average. They have significant power. But, it also presents a lefty-righty-lefty portion of the lineup that strikes fear in opposing pitchers.
You can easily switch Rizzo and Schwarber in the lineup, but there is value in this setup. With Zobrist ahead and Bryant behind, Schwarber is in prime position to see pitches with runners on. He is not as proven as Bryant and Rizzo, so hitting third will give him chances to hit.
Rizzo in the five spot lengthens the lineup, making pitchers run the gauntlet. And, with runners on base, he knows how to adjust to what he is given and score runs. Finally, he takes walks and runs the bases well.